ChoiceQuill is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission. You pay the same price either way.
Shopping for budget-friendly strappy heels on Amazon often leads to the same QIY listing. The shoe is a black stiletto sandal built from faux leather, with a 3 inch heel and a square open toe.
Amazon ranks it #77 in the Women’s Heeled Sandals category. Given how crowded that category is, a position well inside the top 100 is a solid showing.
The price and star rating for this exact listing were out of reach, since Amazon blocks automated access to that data. Guessing would not help anyone.
So this review rests on three things we can verify. They are the stated specs, the category ranking and the way this pair measures up to QIY’s other documented styles.
What the Listing Tells Us
The product title describes a black strappy stiletto sandal. It names a faux leather build, a 3 inch heel and a square open toe.
Standard search tools do not reveal a price or review count for this listing. The figures shown on the page itself are the only dependable ones, so check them there before buying.
That is a genuine limitation. We would rather admit it than make up a star rating.
A Close Relative in QIY’s Catalog
On Modatope’s site, QIY’s official catalog lists a similar style. The Selmira Ankle Strap Sandals cost $39.99, and they are a faux leather stiletto with a 3.15 inch heel and an open toe.
It is a different shoe. Even so, the build and price bracket give a reasonable sense of what a QIY stiletto sandal in this class delivers.
QIY’s documented sandals and heels mostly use faux leather for the upper. Stiletto heels in this range usually run from 3 to 3.74 inches, and ankle-strap styles from the brand often come with a square open toe.
The stated specs on this listing look consistent with everything else in the catalog.
Sizing Notes
The title mentions size 6. Even so, Amazon shoe listings from this brand normally come in a full range of sizes.
Check the sizes on the live listing instead of assuming 6 is your only option.
On the brand’s official site, similar sandals run true, in standard US sizes from 6 to 11. Open-toe stiletto sandals with a 3 inch heel often fit a little roomier at the toe than a closed-toe pump.
Caught between two sizes? The more usual advice is to go down a size for this heel style.
Where You Buy Changes the Return Rules
This detail matters more than it first appears. A purchase through Amazon follows Amazon’s standard return policy, as set for that seller. Modatope’s own policy does not apply.
On Modatope’s own site, returns carry a $6.95 restocking fee, and the items must be unworn.
Amazon listings can vary from seller to seller. Look up the return window on the exact listing page before you commit.
Is It a Good Fit?
Consider it if you are after a square-toe stiletto sandal in the $35 to $50 range that QIY’s similar styles occupy. The listed specs line up with the rest of the catalog, which is the part we could confirm.
Before ordering, confirm the live price and read the seller’s own return policy. Neither detail is something we can vouch for from here.