ChoiceQuill is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission. You pay the same price either way.
Small hoops that hug the ear are an everyday favorite. Ellie Vail’s Erin Huggie Hoop Earring is one of the brand’s best sellers.
Few styles in the catalog have gathered as many reviews as this pair, 83 in all, at a price of $60.
To see whether it deserves that attention, we read a good portion of the feedback along with the brand’s FAQ on materials.
The Materials Behind the Hoop
Every Ellie Vail piece starts with hypoallergenic stainless steel, and the Erin Huggies are no exception. A PVD gold coating then goes over the steel. The brand’s official FAQ puts that coating at 1.5 to 2 microns thick.
Most fast-fashion earrings get a thin electroplated layer instead. This coating is denser and more durable than that.
With a stainless steel core instead of brass or nickel, the hoops are made to withstand sweat, showers and swimming. Rust and green ears should not be a concern.
Two finishes are offered, gold and silver, so you can match whichever metal you prefer.
What Buyers Report
A sample of 83 reviews for one earring style is genuine rather than a few hand-picked testimonials.
Devlin Hopper, one buyer, wrote that they truly love the earrings and find them stylish. The best part, they said, is leaving them in for days or even weeks.
That pattern shows up across Ellie Vail’s feedback as a whole. Buyers tend to keep the pieces on through showers and workouts.
The brand averages 4.6 out of 5 over 6,237 reviews, which adds helpful context. Sizing is the most frequent complaint in the catalog: bangles and rings sometimes run a little bigger than buyers expect.
Huggie hoops avoid most of that, because they are not chosen from a size chart in the same manner.
Fit, Comfort and Plating Care
A huggie hoop rests snugly against the lobe. You can sleep in it, or tuck it under a hood or scarf without catching.
That snug fit is part of the reason reviewers say they keep theirs in for weeks.
The brand’s FAQ warns that lotion or perfume near the ears speeds up plating fade. Daily wearers should keep skincare products clear of the earlobe area to protect the gold.
Where It Fits in the Ellie Vail Range
The Arielle Bangle, the Paola Necklace and the Camden Choker all have fewer reviews than the Erin Huggies. For that reason, the huggies are the safest first purchase for someone new to Ellie Vail.
Ezra Gems sells at a lower price. Choosing Ellie Vail costs more, but it brings a thicker PVD coating and a far longer record of reviews.
Is It Worth Adding to Your Collection?
This is the easiest entry point in the lineup for a shopper who wants a hypoallergenic, water-resistant hoop backed by plenty of reviews.
Protect the plating by keeping lotion and perfume off your ears. Also plan to wear the earrings nonstop, instead of swapping them in and out.