ChoiceQuill is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission. You pay the same price either way.
Sale tags can hide a weak dress, but this one holds up once you look past the discount. It ranks among the best sellers at Scarlet Darkness.
The price is $43.99, marked down from $89.99. The dress is sleeveless with a V-neck and an A-line shape, it closes with a lace-up tie, and it ends in a high-low hem.
We went through the full listing and the fabric spec sheet. To judge whether it is a safe buy, we also looked at how reviewers rate the brand overall.
Fabric and Care
Polyester makes up 82% of the fabric, with 15% cotton and 3% elastane. That blend stretches, so it avoids the stiffness of a costume fabric.
The stretch suits the drawstring lace-up closure, which is meant to adapt to your shape.
The product page lists specific care instructions. Use a normal wash cycle at no more than 30°C, with no bleach.
Skip the tumble dryer, and iron no hotter than 110°C without steam. Dark colors should go in the wash separately.
Colors and Sizes
You can pick from five colors: purple, black, blue, brown or green.
Sizes range from S up to 2XL. The dress therefore sits inside Scarlet Darkness’s extended-size range instead of being limited to standard cuts.
At the front, the lace-up tie adds more room for adjusting the fit than a piece with fixed seams would. That helps if you fall between sizes, since the tie can absorb slack that a rigid zipper could not.
Even so, independent reviews of the brand flag inconsistent sizing across colorways. Rely on the size chart rather than a guess based on a past order.
Brand-Wide Feedback
No large public review thread exists for this exact listing, so we could not pull individual quotes from it. We leaned on the brand-wide pattern instead.
On Trustpilot, Scarlet Darkness holds roughly 3.0 out of 5 from 175 reviews. Opinions are sharply divided.
Some reviewers give five stars for unique pieces that match their photos. Others give one star over sizing and shipping problems.
This dress costs $43.99, which is 51% below its original price. That makes the risk easier to accept than on a $150 corset dress.
If it does not fit, you are not out much. For non-sale items, a 14-day return window serves as a backstop, as long as the tags stay attached and there are no stains.
Next to Similar Dresses
Among the dresses Scarlet Darkness sells, the adjustable closure and the price cut make this one special.
It could also stand in for a similar corset dress from a rival gothic label, and it costs less.
Our Verdict
Are you after a steampunk or Renaissance-adjacent look with real adjustability in the closure? Then this dress is a reasonable low-risk pick, as long as the markdown is still live.
Order by the size chart, not by your usual size from another brand. Leave the tags on until you have confirmed the fit.